Thursday, 17 October 2013
Is Act 3 the climax of the play?
Act 3 is the climax of the play because there is a distinct change in Macbeth's language and general attitude. His voice alters to match the witches, who speak in rhyme and have the power over him. Therefore he gains the power over Lady Macbeth and makes her scared of him. This is important because he has been previously manipulated by her and forced into being a murderer. There is a power shift shown as he takes charge and arranges Banquo's death, without consoling her, she asks the question 'What is to be done?'
He returns to the ruthless and violent man described at the start of the play that has not been shown before through his actions. Thus, after this a t we as readers know from the death and ghost of Banquo, that the end of Macbeth becomes ever closer as it is hinted through the morbid and negative language. Also as Lady Macbeth loses the control Macbeth does more reckless things, which will suggest that bad will come, from this point on everything is set to change, but not necessarily for the better. This would be expected to follow the traditional greek tragedy plots. Lady Macbeth knows they have gone to far and begs Macbeth to do no more. So, therefore the climax is the start of his downfall. Leading up to this point the pace has been rapidly increasing as the incidents happen suggesting the main part of the play, this act to be approaching.
However it could be argued that the climax has not yet occurred and the most crucial part of the play will be the repercussions of the death of Macduff's family which lead to the climax as Macbeth becomes the enemy as all faith is lost in him and the kings son's join together against Macbeth. He is now a threat and foreshadows that a battle will take place so that one of the sides will win and kill the other. This is the first part where Macbeth is accused and loses faith.
Sunday, 13 October 2013
Macbeth Act 3
- Banquo opens the first scene by talking about the concept of Macbeth becoming king, and what he knows from the witches, that his sons will become kings- he may be doubting the quick removal of the king and Macbeth's rise to power.
- Banquo talks( his son Fleance is present) with Macbeth and Lady Macbeth about the upcoming banquet that evening to celebrate, but also mourn the King and the new king.
- They all leave, Macbeth speaks aloud his fears in Banquo as he knows about the weird sisters. This hints and foreshadows that Banquo will have to be removed from the equation as he could be a threat- he needs to be killed.
- Enter three murderers, who Macbeth has ordered to kill Banquo. He is in control for the first time, we can see the soldier- like brave persona only previously talked about, but also a cruel, wicked side also.
- From this point on the pace increases rapidly, as it leads to the climax of the play. The longest act too.
- Macbeth has totally changed now, he speaks more like Lady Macbeth, he has the power. But he does not kill Banquo this time- is he a coward??
- Lady Macbeth and Macbeth talk. She still speaks with the authority, as she rhymes like the witches, but she encourages Macbeth to move on. Macbeth still suffers from the guilt and does not sleep well he exclaims. His state of mind is still muddled, he is constantly worried about being found out- 'O, full of scorpions is my mind, dear wife!' He cannot rest until Banquo and Fleance are dead. Will that really help his mind though? To have his best friend killed, to live with that guilt too?! Or will he get worse?
- Macbeth speech is in rhyming too now.
- Three murderers enter the scene. They attack and murder Banquo, this part is shown to the readers unlike the death of Duncan- does that mean that he is less significant so it won't bother the readers so much?
- Fleance manages to escape.
- The banquet scene. Macbeth and Lady Macbeth welcome their guests. In comes one of the murderers and describes the killing and also the escape of Fleance.
- The ghost of Banquo enters! Only Macbeth can see him though- it unhinges him and questions whether he is disturbed- a gothic feature- the supernatural- is he mentally stable too? Psychological drama. Is it his guilty conscience or the work of the witches?
- Lady Macbeth tries to explain Macbeth's behaviour so not to worry the guests- she says he is having a 'fit'. She takes control again, by asking ' Are you a man?'
- The ghost exits, and calm is resumed.
- The ghost enters again and exits quickly.
- The guests are asked to leave. Banquo is more significant in death to the play, than in life.
- Macbeth and Lady Macbeth argue, Macbeth will meet the weird sisters as it has gone too far now. Macbeth can see no way to get out of this mess he caused. So the only resolution is death, it's hinted, they cannot undo their doings- as greek tragedies end with the protagonist dying/or killing himself the ending is close for Macbeth now.
- The next scene, the witches enter with thunder\(gothic setting). Hecat the queen of all witches is very angry at the other witches for not consoling her in their plotting, she is not happy they have messed with '...riddles and affairs of death'. But she knows Macbeth will come tomorrow and she shall meet them all there. This makes the readers question all that has happened in the play so far, would the play be the same without them? Would Macbeth still kill the king and Banquo? They certainly fill the gaps in the narrative, and their presence is always felt. They change the view of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as they have put the ideas into their heads of power, are they really to blame? They are supernatural- so are the gothic aspect and significant to the analysis.
- Enter Lennox and another Lord. Lennox tells the readers his opinons/ take on the previous events. He does not suspect Macbeth, but now Fleance is- as he ran away, just like the kings sons. He describes Macbeth's killing of the kings guards as 'nobly done', Macbeth was so upset. The lord says Macduff has become a traitor and gone to the king of England for security. The kingdom is falling apart now.
Gothic aspects- death/murder, ghosts- manifestations, the supernatural witches, psychological trauma for Macbeth, foreboding of deaths to come, power shifts.
Monday, 7 October 2013
Greek tragedies
From the internet i found these ideas :
Ancient
tragedy - invented by the ancient Greeks to show the actions of a tragic
hero or heroine. (Ex: Oedipus Rex.)
·
tragic hero/heroine - the protagonist, or main
character, in the play.
·
Aspects of the Greek tragic hero:
·
he/she must be of noble birth or hold
an important social position
·
he/she is generally virtuous
·
he/she has a desire to do good deeds
·
he/she dies in the end of the play
The hero/heroine seems "better" than the
other character(s), but there is a fate which overpowers this "good"
character. Poor judgment by the protagonist (hero/heroine) causes a fall from
grace and social ranking. Poor judgment is a tragic flaw, or error,
called hamatria. It leads to personal catastrophe and
unintended harm to others. Hybris (hubris), which means excessive pride or arrogance, is
the most common type of hamatria. A hero/heroine's misfortune is an example
of human fallibility (human's tendency to
fail). Learning from the
mistakes of others was an important part of Greek tragedy.
·
Aspects of tragedy in Greek drama:
·
crisis of feeling - painful or harmful experience that may upset or depress the
audience.
·
catharsis/purgation - the audience cleanses their emotions. For example, they may feel
uplifted and/or get a new sense of spiritual understanding or tragic pleasure.
·
reversal/peripeteia - the hero/heroine goes through a significant change in fortunefor the worse. Reversal may happen
after a discovery (anagnorisis,)or a recognition of
something previously not known to the hero/heroine.
Act 2- Macbeth reading journals.
Act 2.
- The scene opens with Banquo and his son Fleance awake at night- darkness a key aspect of gothic novels, to create scarygloomy settings, and the idea of hiding, sneaking around late at night.
- Macbeth enters and arranges to discuss the weird sisters with Banquo, as it is on both their minds. This begs the question whether he still believes they exist and that Macbeth is conflicted.
- Macbeth, alone says the famous soliloquy 'Is this a dagger which i see before me?' He hallucinates or imagines a dagger.This shows he is very scared about the act he will commit ( to kill the King). He questions himself and his abilities.
- Enters Lady Macbeth, saying she has set up the crime, shortly followed by Macbeth who returns with bloodstained hands and still carrying the daggers- why does he bring them back in?- he seems to be in shock, not aware/believes what he has just done.
- They talk about Macbeth seeing the bodyguards and talking in their sleep. He believes voices have talked to him and again his sanity is questioned.
- Lady Macbeth takes charge and takes back the daggers into the kings bedroom.
- A knocking sound. This leaves both of them worried- they run away.
- The Porter opens the next scene 3. There is a bridge between the scenes as the knocking continues, this time it is revealed as the front door. The porter is drunk and is comedic, which sets itself from the dark tone after the murder.
- In come Macduff and Lennox ( fellow soldiers)
- Next Macbeth joins them and covers up for his act, claiming the King has not woken yet, but they will go and find him.
- The King is revealed dead.
- Enters Lady Macbeth, they tell her 'tis not for you to hear what i can speak'- she is a woman, she should not deal with evils like this- ironic as she wished to be 'unsexed' and to feel no remorse.
- Enter the kings son's Donalbain and Malcolm- they recieve the news
- Macbeth said he has killed the guards- he has removed the evidence if they were to have woken or known anything.
- Lady Macbeth swoons. Is this her acting along with the gory description of Duncan, or is it her realisation of what she has done, or the anxiety that she may be caught, or the guilt, or just a distraction?
- The sons decide to flee, sensibly, incase they will be killed too.
- Ross enters with and Old Man they talk about the killing of Duncan. They days and nights have changed now 'That darkness does the face of earth entomb When living light should kiss it.' Nature has turned on it's head now Falcons are eaten by Mice, the horses have gone mad and eaten eachother. The world is turned upside down, just like Macbeth has killed the King and now he is King.
- Macduff enters and talks with Ross. They do not suspect Macbeth, but they do suspect the sons of the deceased King, as they fled, could they be hiding something?- we know this is not true.
- Macbeth is crowned.
So far their plan to kill the King has gone well. Now they may feel capable of killing others, possibly Banquo as he knows about the witches and may suspect something, his sons are said to be kings in the prophesy.
Gothic reading:
The supernatural, seeing of the dagger by Macbeth could be the work of the witches, or him going crazy is he sane? Psychological problems and conflicting thoughts cloud his mind.
The darkness makes the play seem sinister (and dark)
Death, greek tragedies lead to more deaths of the main characters.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)